Every Year After Season 1 Episode 5
I Choose You
Drew shows up with an unexpected guest. Meanwhile, Delilah and Charlie reach a crossroads, and Sam makes a life-changing decision-prompting Percy to do whatever she can to distract from her own feelings. Yearning and jealousy are in the air-just like at that New Year's Eve Party in 2015, when Percy's plus one caused a stir, and an unlikely pair shared a midnight kiss.
Guest Stars
Roan Curtis
Taylor
Henry Eikenberry
Mason
Karl Walcott
Drew
Katarina Mueller
Lake
William Wilder
Jake